The Impact of Educational Background on Healthcare Decision-Making

  Mar 11, 2025

Healthcare Decision-Making

We often paint the picture of a healthcare professional’s career to be extremely challenging and demanding, which can be attributed to many reasons. 

Having a high patient turnover, combined with the need to have superior decision-making skills, poses an unending challenge to them.

I have read somewhere that 37% of caregivers in the United Kingdom claimed using the Internet to reach the result (Source: National Institute of Health, 2019).

But to my mind, the single most pivotal factor that has the most impact is the educational background of the healthcare professional. 

How you care for patients and the level of evidence-based medicine and patient-centered care you provide depends on what type and level of knowledge you have received. 

You may now go through this article that explores the impact of different levels of educational background on healthcare decision-making.

The Influence of Advanced Education on Clinical Decision-Making

In healthcare, decision-making is a multifaceted process that requires a balance between clinical expertise, research evidence, and patient-centered approaches. 

As medical knowledge continues to evolve caregivers must rely on their educational backgrounds to interpret complex information, assess risks, and implement appropriate treatments. 

Those with advanced education often possess a deeper understanding of disease mechanisms, treatment modalities, and healthcare policies.

This knowledge and understanding enable them to make more informed and precise decisions in patient care.

A vital distinction exists between practitioners who follow a practice-focused path and those who prioritize research and academia. 

This difference can be seen when comparing a DNP vs PhD since both paths contribute to the advancement of healthcare, however, influence decision-making in distinct ways.

Those with a Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) typically emphasize evidence-based clinical practice and patient care. 

They are trained to integrate research findings into their work and improve outcomes through practical application. 

In contrast, individuals with a Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in nursing focus on generating new knowledge through research. 

Their contributions often shape policies, treatment protocols, and medical advancements which indirectly influence decision-making at the institutional and systemic levels.

A DNP holder applies knowledge directly to patient care to ensure that best practices are followed in real-world scenarios. 

On the other hand, a PhD graduate contributes to the body of knowledge that informs policies to shape the guidelines that practitioners follow. 

The Role of Education in Evidence-Based Practice

Evidence-based practice (EBP) is a cornerstone of modern healthcare decision-making and is heavily dependent on a caregiver’s educational background.

Professionals with extensive academic training are more likely to necessarily evaluate research findings, assess their applicability to specific cases, and implement effective treatments. 

Their education equips them with the analytical skills needed to differentiate between high-quality studies and those with methodological flaws. 

In addition, they develop the ability to adapt research findings to diverse clinical settings and ensure that treatments are both scientifically valid and practically feasible.

Conversely, those with less formal training may rely more on traditional methods, institutional protocols, or personal experience. 

The image below consists of statistics that show the value of automating patient communication.

Statistics on the Value of Automating Patient Communication

Educational Background and Patient Communication

Effective communication between healthcare providers and patients is necessary for informed decision-making. 

People who are under medical treatment rely on medical professionals to explain conditions, outline treatment options, and provide guidance on managing illnesses. 

The way a provider conveys this information is shaped by their educational background.

Higher education equips caregivers with stronger communication skills, including the ability to explain complex medical concepts in accessible language. 

Those with advanced training are more likely to employ shared decision-making strategies, where they are actively involved in choosing their treatment plans. 

They understand the importance of patient autonomy and work to ensure that individuals feel empowered to make informed choices about their health.

On the other hand, professionals with less advanced education may take a more directive approach.

A guideline must provide recommendations without fully engaging the people under medical treatment in the regulating process.

Though this approach may be efficient in certain clinical settings, it can lead to misunderstandings or decreased patient satisfaction. 

The Impact of Education on Ethical Decision-Making

Ethical dilemmas are common in healthcare that require professionals to balance medical knowledge, legal considerations, and moral responsibilities. 

Educational background plays a significant role in shaping how caregivers navigate these challenges.

Those with extensive academic training are more likely to have a strong foundation in medical ethics, equipping them with the tools to address complex scenarios. 

They are trained to analyze ethical dilemmas using established frameworks, ensuring that their decisions align with professional standards and legal guidelines. 

It helps them navigate difficult situations, such as end-of-life care decisions, conflicts between patient wishes and medical advice, and issues related to resource allocation.

Without a comprehensive background in ethics, healthcare providers may rely on personal beliefs or institutional policies.

This can lead to inconsistencies in care, where ethical considerations vary based on the provider’s level of education rather than standardized guidelines.

Do You Know?
Approximately 66% of family caregivers are women.

Leadership and Policy Development in Healthcare

Education not only impacts individual decision-making but also influences leadership roles and policy development within the medical care system. 

Healthcare professionals with advanced academic training often take on leadership positions.

It is where they influence organizational policies, advocate for patient rights, and contribute to systemic improvements.

Those with extensive education are more likely to be involved in policy formulation which ensures that healthcare guidelines reflect current research and best practices. 

Their ability to analyze medical care trends, assess policy implications, and propose evidence-based solutions makes them valuable contributors to the industry’s evolution. 

In contrast, those with less academic training may have limited opportunities to shape policy decisions. 

Though experience provides valuable insights, it may not be sufficient for engaging in high-level discussions about wellness regulations and systemic improvements. 

Advanced education equips professionals with the knowledge and analytical skills needed to advocate for change.

This ultimately shapes the future of healthcare at an institutional and governmental level.

All in all, educational background significantly influences regulations by shaping clinical reasoning, patient communication, ethical considerations, and policy development. 

Advanced education enhances a professional’s ability to apply evidence-based practices, navigate ethical dilemmas, and engage in shared decision-making with patients. 




×